We receive advertising fees from the brands we review which affect the ranking and scoring. We receive advertising fees from the brands we review. These fees affect the ranking and scoring. We do not compare all service providers in the market. Featured prices and terms can be updated. Free offers may include additional terms. Full Advertiser Disclosure

ConsumerIQ.co is a website that allows users to find and compare products and services. We believe in helping our users make informed decisions about the products and services they buy.

We may receive advertising fees from the brands we review, which is how we're able to keep our site free for everyone to use. These advertising fees, combined with our criteria and methodology, our team of reviewer's findings, subjective experience, and product popularity, impact the placement and position of the brands within the comparison table or our quote matching technology. We do our best to keep up-to-date on the latest offer terms of our partners but they can change at any time.

ConsumerIQ.co does not compare all suppliers in the market and not all products or services are available at all times, through all channels, or in all areas. Not all products and services from our partners are compared by ConsumerIQ.co and due to commercial arrangements and customer circumstances, not all products and services offered by ConsumerIQ.co are available to all customers.

For more information please see How We Rate and our Terms of Use.

Top Home Warranty

Last Updated November 2024

A home warranty is a service contract that covers the repair or replacement of certain home systems and appliances, such as heating and air conditioning systems, electrical systems, plumbing, and major appliances like refrigerators and dishwashers. It is typically purchased by the homeowner and can provide peace of mind and financial protection in the event of a covered breakdown. The terms and coverage of a home warranty can vary, so it’s important to carefully review the details of the contract before purchasing.

Top 3 Best Home Warranty for you

Most Recommended
American Home Shield
  • Out of network contactors
  • Quick and efficient contractor dispatch
  • No home inspection required
  • Constant contactor quality evaluation
Our Score
9.8
Read Review
Americas First Choice
  • Out of network contactors
  • No home inspection required
  • Unlimited number of service requests
  • Work guaranteed for life of plan
Our Score
9.5
Read Review
OFFER
Choice Home : $50 off + 1 month free
  • Over 15,000 5 Star Reviews
  • 24/7 in our call centers
  • 5,000,000 Service Requests
  • Nationwide Network of 25,000+ Contractors
  • Covered 1,650,000+ Homes Across the USA
Our Score
9.4
Read Review
Cinch
  • On demand contactors
  • 180-day workmanship guarantee
  • Easy to use online portal
  • Multiple payment options
Our Score
9.2
Read Review
First American
  • No home inspection required
  • No individual coverage limits
  • Broad coverage included in base plans
  • Unlimited number of claims
Our Score
9.0
Read Review
First Premier
  • Low service call-out fee’s
  • Customizable coverage plans
  • Regular signup bonuses
  • Straightforward claims policy
Our Score
8.9
Read Review
Liberty Home Guard
  • Regular signup bonuses
  • Multiple plan coverage options
  • No home inspection required
  • Discount on annual and multi-year plans
Our Score
8.4
Read Review
Select
  • Extensive repair contractor network
  • Same-day response on claims
  • Discount on annual and multi-year plans
  • Free roof coverage
Our Score
8.0
Read Review
OFFER
2-10 Home warranty : $150 off + 1 month free
  • Trusted For Over 25 Years
  • 30 Day Money-Back Guarantee
  • 25,000+ Contractors Nationwide
  • 24/7 Customer Service
Our Score
8.0
Read Review
The Home Services Club
  • Extensive system and appliance coverage
  • Provides coverage for pest damage
  • Adjustable service call-out fee
  • Nationwide coverage
Our Score
7.0
Read Review

What is a Home Warranty?

A home warranty plan is a coverage plan that protects the systems and appliances in your home from the inevitable breakdown and inefficiency that comes from normal wear and tear or mechanical deficiency.

Without a home warranty plan, any time your air conditioning or how water system breaks down, or an appliance stops working, you will be on the hook for the entire cost of the repair or replacement. With a home warranty plan, you can have these costs covered with only a monthly premium and a small service fee.

How does Home Warranty benefit you?

When your essential home systems and appliances break down, repairs or replacement can be very expensive. Items such as your television, dishwasher and air conditioning unit will come with time-limited manufacturer’s warranty, but after this has expired, all costs are then on you.

A home warranty plan can cover all these major systems and appliances and ensure you will not be significantly out of pocket when these unexpected breakdowns occur. All these items will inevitably break down at some point due to normal wear and tear. So as long as you hold a home warranty plan, there will generally always be a time when you need to rely on it.

How much does Home Warranty cost?

There are two parts to the cost of a home warranty. The first is the monthly premium, which based on the provider, can also be paid as an annual premium with a discount. The market average for the monthly premium sits at around $40 per month.

The other cost involved in a home warranty plan is the service call out fee. This is payable for every claim made, and is generally paid out directly to the technician. The usual fee is around $125, with some providers offering a reduction in the service fee, but this will increase the monthly premium.

Home Warranty vs Home Insurance

Home warranty covers the internal operating systems and appliances that may – or will eventually – break down due to normal wear and tear. Replacement or repair can cost you thousands of dollars, so a home warranty coverage can help protect you against this.

Home insurance on the other hand protects your house, furniture and appliances from damage. So if for example a fire or flood damages your home, this is all covered under your insurance.

How to choose the right Home Warranty?

Every home warranty provider out there provides slightly different coverage. Being able to compare different providers can ensure you take up the coverage that will be the best for your situation.

The first consideration is what you are wanting to cover. Most providers have separate plans for appliances, systems, and a combination. Providers such as Americas First Choice and Liberty Home Guard are examples of this. Otherwise the providers will have plans which cover a mix of systems and appliances, to varying levels and inclusions. Choice and First Premier are examples of providers with this sort of coverage.

You will also need to consider how well your items have been maintained prior to the coverage. Most providers will not cover pre-existing conditions. If you do want to have coverage of the pre-existing conditions of your items, then a provider such as Cinch might be the best for you.

The next item to consider is the cost. This is both the monthly or annual premium, but also the coverage cap on each item. You do not want to find yourself in a situation where you are paying a cheap premium, but then are only covered for a small portion of a claim, and still find yourself thousands of dollars out of pocket.

You will also need to consider the duration of the workmanship guarantee that each providers offers. This can vary greatly, from not offering any guarantee, to as long as the lifetime duration of the coverage plan, Americas First Choice is one example of this.

Conclusion

For most homeowners, a home warranty plan is absolutely worth the money. The cost of repairing and replacing your essential home systems or appliances can quickly rack up, and it is completely unexpected when these items will break down.

For just a monthly premium and small service fee, you can save yourself thousands of dollars when the inevitable happens.

Each provider offers slightly different features in their coverage plans, so it is best to compare each provider to find out which one will best suit you.

Most Recommended
American Home Shield
  • Out of network contactors
  • Quick and efficient contractor dispatch
  • No home inspection required
  • Constant contactor quality evaluation
Our Score
9.8
Read Review
NEW! Special Offers

Get Free Quotes

Claim Offer

GET $5 FREE + 5% cashback

Claim Offer